Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

First of all, I would like to state that just because a piece of software is free and open source, does not mean it is inherently more secure or private. "Open source" is merely just a licensing term.

GrapheneOS has the "App Store" to get the most basic apps required for general usage. Accrescent is distributed there because it follows Android's security baseline for being an actual app repository while F-Droid and Aurora Store do not. There really isn't a value in having third parties compiling apps to check for any malicious activity, which F-Droid does. These checks are not reliable and have been bypassed. It's one of the reasons why Wireguard is no longer on F-Droid. If you don't trust an app enough to get it directly from the developer, then don't use the app at all. The privacy and security benefits of GrapheneOS are supposed to be nearly invisible to the average user. Examples include a hardened memory allocator and memory tagging extension to protect from memory corruption bugs, and the ability to install sandboxed Google Play to use Google services without Google having complete control of your device.



I trust F-Droid. I don't trust millions of developers. I don't have time everytime I need an app to go investigate, especially now with quick LLM scam app developer

Developers are not geniuses at every aspect of security or app deployment. They can sell their projects. Get compromised. Or can get tricked like the xz exploit

Having an app store making any effort to prevent or correct problems, especially as transparent as F-Droid, is better

Wireguard app dev wanting to bypass the store and push an executable to your phone every day is ridiculous. No user of app/package manager expects it to be bypassed


Please study the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XZ_Utils_backdoor That is the supply chain attack I know and it was discovered in debian with their outdated build system. Your arguments, which copy exactly those of the "grapheneos people", seem ignorant and arrogant to me. F-droid people are doing a lot of work for free, I think they deserve more respect than you give them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: