Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, I'd rather we raise the basic income for every adult enough to the point where the adult can support themselves and ONE (1) child at least for bare necessities like food and shelter.

For what it is worth, I don't think anyone sane would have kids to get money. In fact, you couldn't pay me to have children and raise them. I know what a shitty brat I've been and I'm sure if God or karma exists, I'll get an equally shitty child or worse I'll make a very shitty parent. (Parents: yes, people without kids also have nightmares about fucking up as parents)

Thankfully though many if not most people want children even though it makes no sense. This is good for me because these are the kids who will build and maintain roads, hospitals, and electric lines when our generation can no longer walk without a cane.

I don't think we need to encourage people to have many children. Those who want multiple children should find alternate ways to fund their lifestyle.

Edit: I assume above that basic healthcare for everyone exists with $0 out of pocket even if it is some couple's 99th child.



Unfortunately, the racist caricature of the 'welfare queen' who will go out of her way to work 24/7 for 18+ years for welfare benefits that equate to less than the pay of a part time job has been used to drive conservatives to the polls since the 1980's.

It's well cemented in the public consciousness as a result, so you'll see it trotted out whenever monetary benefits are proposed to help children.


The key is to arguing that it is a minor drain on the proposed system and appeal to the moral high ground. Don't deny all the good people help because you want to deny a few bad people help. There will always be leeches on any system.

No idea at all how to do that though.


>I know what a shitty brat I've been and I'm sure if God or karma exists, I'll get an equally shitty child or worse I'll make a very shitty parent.

Man, that kept me up many a night before my kid was born! She turned out to be amazing, though. Definitely didn't get it from me.

We had to rely on EBT (food stamps) and Medicaid when she was little and we were both in college. Medicaid was amazing, at least for someone who couldn't afford to go to a doctor for a decade or more beforehand, but besides that perk the welfare benefits for having a child basically balanced out the increased costs of raising one. Can't say how well this would scale with n+1 kids though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: