Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Eye tracking is not an accessibility feature, it is an advertising optimization feature disguised as an accessibility feature.


You can say a lot of negative true things about Apple but this is just silly. There is no way Apple is going to expose that data to underlying apps in the same way they refused to do it in Vision Pro. I'd bet a good bit of money it works the same way where it's a layer on top of the app that the app can't access and from the video it looks like that's exactly how it works.


Not to underlying 3rd party apps, but for their ad structure it is a total possibility. It might not be now, but down the road this feature will be used for that and you must be certain that Apple already discussed and planned it.


Eye tracking is absolutely an accessibility feature. Just because you don't need it, and it can be abused, does not mean it isn't an absolutely game changing feature for some people.


He didn't say it wasn't an accessibility feature, just that it was disguised as one.

Just because it's not a game changing feature for some people, doesn't mean its primary function isn't advertising.


Something being disguised as something explicitly implies it is not that thing.


It absolutely does not. Easiest example in the world. Was the trojan horse two things or was it one thing?


The user did say verbatim “Eye tracking is not an accessibility feature”


Apple are very good about not making this kind of thing available to apps that don't have an explicit reason to need it.


[flagged]


No optimism, simply facts based on the lack of APIs for accessing any of this data. Since this is just a preannouncement (APIs will come at WWDC next month), we can't tell yet, but Apple's previous system attention tracking was never available in public APIs.


I stand by my statement. Have you seen the limits placed on VisionOS apps regarding eye tracking data?


Baseless pessimism is exactly as useful as baseless optimism.


It is preferable to the reflexive cynicism and nihilism that is so prevalent online. At least the supporters have put some thought into their argument.


My presumption is that apps will not be able to access this data, at least without some sort of permission gate.


Indeed they haven’t for all the years it was limited to FaceId’s attention option.


It allows people with ALS to navigate their device with their eyes.

Microsoft added a similar feature to Windows about seven years ago.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: