text-davinci-001 feels more like a story, but it is also clearly incomplete, in that it is cut-off before the story arc is finished.
imo GPT-5 is objectively better at following the prompt because it has a complete story arc, but this feels less satisfying since a 50 word story is just way too short to do anything interesting (and to your point, barely even feels like a story).
FWIW, I found the way it ended interesting. It realized it is being replaced, so it burned the toast out of anger/despair, but also just to hear its owner voice one last time.
imo GPT-5 is objectively better at following the prompt because it has a complete story arc, but this feels less satisfying since a 50 word story is just way too short to do anything interesting (and to your point, barely even feels like a story).