Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think nothing less than a revolution in the way humans think is going to solve these problems. I mean, science solves problems better than witchcraft for a reason. Mankind is still using the equivalent of witchcraft in the legal realm.


Complete with arcane mutterings. I know that law has a lot of very specific terms, but is encoding them in Latin necessary?


It's not like they sat together in 1960 and decided to agree upon a set of latin terms for everyday occurrences - these are mostly inherited.

The idea is to keep the language reasonably stable that we can still confidently interpret legalese from 1812, and that in 2412 the legal body of 2012 can still be of some use without having historians fight over how we might have meant things.

This is particularly true in letter-of-law + case law jurisdictions - in spirit-of-law jurisdictions, interpretation is always required, while in non-case law jurisdictions, rulings don't have as much impact so you don't have to care about what was ruled 200 years ago.


At this rate, any of these laws remaining relevant in 2412 is highly optimistic.


Did you know the property law that forms the bedrock of our society dates back to feudal times?


More through inertia than desire, i.e. past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Change accelerates, and feudal times was not much more than 400 years ago in the scheme of things.


It's very rare to see Latin in any modern legal document. And legal documents are hardly arcane. They're verbose and specific, full of terminology, but not purposefully arcane.


It is necessary to create an aura of legitimacy.

As I was reading through the legalese for the MPLA, I realized that the typical practices of the legal profession have about as much to do with reality as Dungeons and Dragons. They are playing games with words, the only difference is that they're dealing not with game pieces but with your very life.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: